Final Parcel of a Mt. Sinai Family’s Farming Legacy Goes Up For Sale

Local family has been part of the community since the turn of the century.

The Niegocki siblings have reluctantly decided to sell the family farm bringing an end to a legacy that they say has lasted 100 years and spread out over 120 acres in Mt. Sinai.

Almost a century ago, Anthony Niegocki Sr. traveled east from Hicksville to purchase a large swath of land in Mt. Sinai. When the elder Niegocki’s son, Anthony Jr., met his future wife Joanna Bubka at a dance in Eastport, the two settled down to scratch out a living in the dirt, farming the front parcel for his father, growing potatoes, cauliflower and cabbage among other crops. They bought the property in 1941.

Over the ensuing decades, the Niegocki farm was slowly portioned off. In the early 1960s, 96 acres of the farm to the northeast was sold off and became a residential subdivision off of Jesse Way. According to the family, another 25 acres was sold to Panfield Nursery and McGoverns Sod Farm. That piece eventually became part of Heritage Park.

All that is left of over 120 acres of farmland is a two-story white and green farmhouse and a wooden barn on a little under four acres of property fanning out between Mount Sinai Coram Road and North Ocean Avenue (Route 83).

Last July, Joanna Niegocki passed away at 90-years-old, three years after her husband Anthony Jr. died at age 91. That four-acre remnant is now up for sale, perhaps to be snatched up by a developer who can cut it up into even smaller parcels.

The Niegocki children aren’t happy about it but it’s something they know they must do.

“It’s not good,” said Ray, one of the Niegocki’s four children – three boys and one girl – who just happened to be reuniting this week for the wedding of his son Matthew. Ray stood on the front porch of the farmhouse along with his brothers Joe and Stanley and his sister Terry Sclefani. Stanley and Ray both still live on Long Island. Joe retired to North Carolina. Terry lives in Tennessee.

“It sucks,” said Stanley echoing his brother’s sentiment.

The Niegocki sons and daughter would rather see the property farmed, or instead of having a stranger come in to subdivide the property, they’d like to do it themselves.

“For us to do it, it would take ten years,” said Stanley.

He said it would take more money and political influence than he and his siblings had in order to get it done.

Fred Drewes, chairman of Heritage Park's Farm Committee, told Patch that he's thought about the Niegocki property for years and said that it's a small but import key to a central open space within Mt. Sinai.

"[The Niegocki farm and the Heritage Park] form a core of space that is a breathe of fresh air in our built-out community," he said.

While Drewes has some ides on what could be done with the property - like using the farmhouse as mid 20th century period museum and the fields for community gardens - he said that someone would have to pay to preserve it.

"No one gets a free lunch so if this property could be added to our public assets then government and citizens must pay," he said. "I hope that is possible but am not sure who would carry the flag."

No one lives in the house anymore and the reasons to sell at this time are mixed. For some of the children it’s a matter of finances. For others, it’s just time to let it go.

The property hasn’t been farmed in years. The last crop grown there according to the children were tomatoes, cucumbers and peppers.

When Anthony Jr. died, his children said that he wanted to be buried behind the barn on the property because the farm “gave him life.”

They couldn’t grant his request but his widow was able to get a bench in his honor placed across the street in Heritage Park, a portion of which was once part of the Niegocki’s farmland.

The bench – located next to the Heritage Center and faces their old farmhouse – has a gold plaque on it that reads: The gift of life this year – 2008. Anthony and Joanna Niegocki. Together farming this land and the land across the street since 1941.

christine August 10, 2012 at 04:53 PM
Nice article. I remember driving by the farm years ago & seeing items for sale out front. Best wishes for the family.
karen August 10, 2012 at 05:10 PM
So sad that a developer will probably make it smaller parcels. Such a shame that no one can help them restart a farm. Best of luck to the family.
Danielle Costags August 10, 2012 at 05:14 PM
They use to have the best farm stand
micki August 10, 2012 at 06:55 PM
this parcel should be a continuation of heritage park...another ball field of some sorts. an indoor swimming pool for lessons. indoor ice skating. lots of possibilities.
Louis Antoniello August 11, 2012 at 10:47 AM
I am familiar with the propery. Anyone who grew up in thee area remembers the farm. I think the family needs to try the preservation route before placing the property on the "for sale" list. There are many communities whose "Carbon Footprint" continues to grow endangering health and quality of life. The Town needs to preserve more open space preserved,It may not happen in time for this farm, but I sugeest, again, that the Town and the tax payers revisit the 1/4 penny sales tax . It is an inexpensive way to preserve open space. For the present I would suggets the family sit down with the Heritage Trust (I believe this is the correct title) in Mount Sinai and see what can be done. Just some thoughts.
Justin Time August 11, 2012 at 10:55 AM
I smell a strip mall.
KimP August 11, 2012 at 12:46 PM
I would love to buy this and all the properties like it. My families farm in upstate NY went to the Amish so at least someone is still farming it, but what a loss to my children. I spent summers up there on the farm and it was a blast.... Sorry to see another family lose their legacy.
kenneth himmel August 11, 2012 at 05:29 PM
"No one gets a free lunch so if this property could be added to our public assets then government and citizens must pay," he said. "I hope that is possible but am not sure who would carry the flag."The government and citizens must pay?Like the government has its own money to spend,it comes from the citiizens.I hope people of Brookhaven stop electing politicians with the mindset of Mr.Drewes
John Ryan August 11, 2012 at 05:33 PM
More evidence of local history condemned to death, I like the ''Amish'' idea a lot...I am willing to bet the powers that be can't wait to get it on the tax rolls as commercial or sub division properties
Yvonne Affronti August 11, 2012 at 10:28 PM
So much of the past gets torn down and destroyed. It's very sad that the true character of a place cannot stay for all of us to learn from. I am a preservationist. Unfortunately, I have no money to contribute to this but would support some sort of movement to raise funds for the cause. "Once it's gone, it's gone". I live in a mid-nineteenth century home and had owned a late 18th century home in New England. It's a labor of love but it adds so much to the community: history, texture and character. I hope something can be done to save it.
KaLee H August 12, 2012 at 06:32 AM
Can't bear the thought of that house not being there! I hope something happens to save it.. I feel peaceful & happy whenever I pass this house! It is what Mt Sinai once was. 35 years ago when we moved out here I loved that house & still do.. It is part of our history, our community! Also they were lovely people and we enjoyed years of stopping by several times a week for our good & fresh produce!!
Justin Time August 12, 2012 at 12:36 PM
Most people can't bear the thought of leaving their house. Unfortunately, the HIGH property taxes are forcing familes to leave. This is a sad thing for all involved. Since nothing is being done to vote NO on the budgets, you will see more of this happening on Long Island. Get used to it!
Yvonne Affronti August 12, 2012 at 11:08 PM
It's true we're in a pickle with taxes and the economy is not helping. There should be some relief to keep the "quality of life" which includes the historic structures that were there before any of us preserved. Or here we come, Queens Boulevard.
Mary E August 20, 2012 at 02:25 AM
I would love to see the home and property preserved. A community garden is a wonderful idea. Selling the produce would generate revenue to maintain the property. Anthony and Joanna were lovely people and they would appreciate our caring for their legacy. Mary E.
moethegrass August 21, 2012 at 08:20 PM
Let's see what does this bucolic area need. I got it. A pizzeria, a chinese restaurant, a dry cleaners, a 7-11, and perhaps a gas station. Cause you know that nothing gets elected officials more excited than the same old thing. Strip Mall!
meg supeck January 26, 2013 at 11:03 PM
This kind gentleman farmer took his time with me when i asked him how to cook the beets i used to buy from him, that were so beautiful and delish. He had that great farmers face and hands. They also grew the nicest sunflowers, Any time we had a party i made sure i filled the house with them. When i passed the home one day i saw the sign that said, i believe, goodbye grandpa. This farm family and many other features of this town made me fall in love with mount sinai. We should continue to fight to keep the integrity of this farming town, and keep it grrreeeennnn.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something