Assaults, Robberies, and Drugs: Oh My!

Residents Fear Increased Crime Wave May Be New Norm for Port Jeff - YOU DECIDE!

If you haven’t heard the latest hot button issue facing Port Jeff, you might just be living under a rock. It’s hard to miss the blazing emotions sweeping the Port Jefferson/PJS area following major reports of violent felonies plaguing the community. We’ve been hearing what Port Jeff Patch readers and locals have to say and the coconscious is pretty clear – the violence and crime just needs to stop!

So, how serious is this? Is it just a weird coincidence or is there really a clear pattern of criminal behavior developing around our hometown? It’s a question that I have been pondering, asking, and just can’t get a clear answer on. So I went ahead and reviewed Crime Reports and local news listings for incidents around the Port Jefferson Village and PJ Station areas for the last few weeks. Go ahead, take a look at the facts and you decide.

  1. Last Friday, a man was violently assaulted and robbed at the Long Island Railroad Station in Port Jeff. His head was split open with an unknown object and his prescription medication, cash, and cell phone were taken. The MTA police are conducting an investigation, but no arrests have been made. I asked the MTA if they would increase patrols following the incident, and MTA Spokesman Salvatore Arena said, “The MTA PD believes its current patrol strategy with officers in sector cars and on trains is working successfully. Incidents of crime at the railroad station are rare. In fact, the attack on Friday night in which a homeless man was set upon, beaten and robbed, was the first such incident this year. In 2011, there were none. In addition, MTA PD has already stepped up its enforcement of LIRR quality of life violations such as smoking, drinking, etc.”
  2. Following an early morning altercation on Saturday August 5th, a man was stabbed in front of the McDonalds on West Broadway in Port Jeff Village. According to reports, the man was stabbed multiple times and the assailant fled the scene. Witnesses reported seeing a trail of blood leading to the benches in front of Village Hall, where the victim was found. He was later transported to Stony Brook University Medical Center for his injuries. An investigation is ongoing, and police have not yet made an arrest.
  3. A man riding his bicycle behind Jefferson Plaza on Route 112 in Port Jeff Station, just a little bit more than 1,000 feet from the Port Jeff LIRR Station, was robbed at gunpoint for his wallet. No arrests have been made.  
  4. A cashier at 7-11 on Route 112 in Port Jefferson Station was assaulted in what was reported as an unprovoked attack. According to reports, an undomiciled man, Glenn Johnson, 30, entered the 7-11 at 408 Route 112 on July 23rd. He removed a bottle of water from the refrigerator and then punched the cashier in the face. The employee was taken to Mather Hospital and Mr. Johnson was arrested by Suffolk County Police. A spokesperson for 7-11 could not immediately comment on the incident, but did tell me that 7-11 has a crime deterrent program in which all of their franchisees are trained in, as well as tactics to not provoke shoplifters. 7-11 also has Loss Prevention Officers who oversee security operations. A manager at the 7-11 location declined to comment as to the well-being of the assaulted employee, but did say that the store regularly sees shoplifting activity.
  5. Samantha Knab and Michael Wills were arrested following a month long burglary spree. The couple who allegedly burglarized homes in Port Jefferson Station and surrounding areas were arrested by police while trying to break into a sixth home.
  6. According to reports, a security guard from Arrow Security was assaulted after spotting Sean McMahon, 42, of Medford, taking items from Bravo Supermarket without paying for them. According to witnesses, McMahon shoved the guard to the ground and fled. McMahon was later arrested while causing a disturbance at Mather Hospital. A manager at Bravo, who identified himself only as George, told me “there is a lot of shoplifting and people trying to steal here.” When asked if he thought increased patrols during specific hours would help tame shoplifting and crime in the area, he told me “there is no specific time – they are always stealing”.
  7. A Port Jefferson Station woman, Christina Sherman, 21, and an accomplice, Anna Joskowska, were both arrested on accusation of robbing six and eight homes, respectively, of jewelry and cash, including at least one in Port Jefferson Station, according to police. Sherman, who was arrested at her home in Port Jefferson Station, was arraigned on July 23rd and charged with six counts of Burglary in the 2nd Degree. She pled not guilty, but remains in county jail, where she did not post bail, and faces up to 90 years if convicted. Jaskowska was charged with eight counts, after being arrested at the SCPD Sixth Precinct.
  8. Police were called in June to The Port Jefferson Beverage Center on Railroad Avenue in Port Jefferson Station, where the front door had been damaged. The reason behind the act of vandalism remains unknown.  
  9. In late June, in separate incidents, police were called to respond when two different men were punched in the face by an unknown black assailant. One in front of Islandwide Transportation in Upper Port Jefferson Village and one in front of 7-11 on Route 112 in Port Jefferson Station.
  10. A woman called Suffolk Police on June 23rd to report that she was assaulted by a group of people she identified as three black men and a Hispanic woman. According to reports, she was punched in the face, thrown to the ground, and kicked. 


Although both Suffolk County Police and the Port Jefferson Code Enforcement Division have increased patrols in the area, many residents fear these incidents are indicative of a larger, serious crime pattern developing.

Residents have been sounding off on Port Jeff Patch, in the comments section, and the feedback following these happenings is just not good. Criticisms to the Police, local elected officials and the Village Board seem to be a recurring theme. Multiple readers expressed the same question, “Does someone have to die for our politicians and police to take action in PJS/PJ Village?”

One Port Jeff Patch reader put it bluntly in her Facebook comment “Something has got to be done! Either a change is going to come, or I’m moving out of PJ!”   

What do you think? Is this pattern of violent criminal behavior becoming the norm in Port Jeff? I want to hear from you, your suggestions and how you feel about this. Post in the comments below, send me an e-mail or follow me on Twitter @heymike76.

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

ualready August 08, 2012 at 01:12 PM
How do expect the police to do anything when they have no physical evidence, although it is obvious that those items were not of their property that doesn't mean that they can just take them in for possessing them, that would be a false arrest and the needles? what do you expect DNA testing? If that were me and my husband I would of dealt with that ourselves because the police ain doin jack sheeet,.
Americanivory August 08, 2012 at 08:04 PM
Hey dummy - the evidence was in their car - note the "found numerous GPS's, laptops, cameras, and other electronics in their car" and my husband caught them!!! As for the needles I would expect beefed up patrols, we live right next to park where children play - apparently it is NOT diabetics they are on the look out for!! And how exactly would you and your husband deal with this yourselves? We pay the police to protect us from the dredges of society. Think before you write....
ualready August 08, 2012 at 08:50 PM
Hey asshole just because its in there car doesnt mean anything. They caught them with merchandise whos to say it wasnt theirs I mean OBVIOUSLY its not, but as I said before they did not catch them in the act of stealing it. IF in fact they stole items out of your car and the police caught them in the act thats a totally different story THATS evidence i would of took a picture of them trying to break into my car and showed the police thats what i would of done..and what do you expect the police to do about the needles??? if they told you people were shooting dope would you be pleased i dont get it?? ...people also pay taxes for schools meanwhile they have no kids yea life doesnt make sense get the fuck over it you want peace move somewhere else
Americanivory August 08, 2012 at 09:03 PM
Are you a nut? Dd you take the time to read??? How about the part about the needles "As for the needles I would expect beefed up patrols,..." that would mean more patrolling of the area knowing there are drug dealings going on - and who is talking about school taxes? Lot's of things you "would have done" - big talk form a little a-hole!! And yes I am selling my house to get out of this slum full of degenerates and dummies...
ualready August 10, 2012 at 06:40 AM
First of all ... If you live in port jeff station you know that there are cops EVERYWHERE they already increased the amount of police, if you havent noticed there is a big electronic sign clearly stating "increased patrols" on your way to and from the train tracks ..Second of all im comparing school taxes to "We pay the police to protect us from the dredges of society."-im saying how can you complain about that when people pay taxes for things they dont even use in anyway as in schools.Third and last of all what I would of done I think would of been a better idea than what you would have done , BUT thats just my opinion feel free to think what you want...later


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »