.

Blogger: Aldi Supermarket is Like a Journey to an Alternate Universe

My journey to the alternate reality of Aldi Supermarket and my look into the abyss of my own consumerism.

Disclaimer: My wife wanted me to tell you that I was not a loser in High School. In fact I was awesome, awesome I tell you...

When I was a teenager I was into Stephen King. I was a sad, lonely boy and I used to read his books between sessions of Dungeons and Dragons and being rejected by girls. In hindsight it seems pathetic. But what you don’t know is that I was actually preparing for my inevitable confrontation with a parallel universe.

While other young men were enjoying the superfluities of life (dating, driving, not living with their mother), I was developing the psychological resilience needed to function in another world - a world similar to our own but profoundly different. After all these years, my journey to the hinterlands of space and time is finally complete. I give you, my intrepid readers, .

It opened last month, innocuously enough, where the old Circuit City used to be near Smith Haven Mall. There was little fanfare and I don’t remember seeing even the standard “grand opening” signs posted on the sidewalk out front. It was just there one day; doors open for business, as if it has been there all along. I found myself drawn to the place, pulled there by some strange gravity, until I finally wandered in.

In one of Stephen King’s novel, I believe it was a Dark tower book, the main characters travel into another book, The Stand. I know it is convoluted, but bear with me. The Stand is set on earth, but a version of reality slightly different than our own. For example, in the scene I remember, they are walking through a deserted supermarket parking lot. Most of the population has been wiped out by a plague and all the cars are simply abandoned. One of the characters, who is from our reality, starts to read the names of the cars. He notices that there are Toyotas and Fords, but also made up ones like Stewarts or Maharishi (I don’t remember the exact names, but you get the gist). They looked like our cars, the lines were the same, the colors and shapes, but they were also horribly wrong and alien because they were so different and yet so mundane.

By this point you are probably saying, jeez he was a loser in high school. That’s mean. It is also beside the point. You should be asking what does all this have to do with the new supermarket that opened in Smithtown? Well read on...

When we walked in, all the products looked like the stuff you would see in any normal store on Long Island. The isles were Spartan, they had a BJ’s or Costco feel, but for the most part if looked like an ordinary supermarket. It had perfectly normal displays, things groups together in a logical way, even the colors and packaging was correct. But there was something very, very wrong. 

My daughter was the first to notice it. She picked up the familiar yellow and blue jar of Hellmann’s mayonnaise. Only it wasn’t Hellmann’s, it was Bermans. Berman’s mayonnaise - right there on the label - the Hellmann’s label. Even the font was the same. It took a moment to sink in. I looked at the Gatorade display - but it wasn’t Gatorade. Same thing with the saltines, baked beans, chips, you name it. It was one of those moments where the world spins and all the air gets sucked out of the room. My mind simply couldn’t comprehend what is happening, it had to reboot itself.

I must have lost consciousness for a few seconds, I don’t know. The next thing I remember was feeling cold. I came to lying on the ground, my cheek pressed up against one of the meat refrigerators. I staggered to my feet and picked up a package of chop meat. It was very cheap, an excellent deal, but I didn’t trust it. All I could hear was alarm bells in my head - MAD COW, MAD COW - over and over in the singsong rhythm of a claxon. My wife was online, buying something that looks disturbingly like cheerios. I rushed over to her just as she finished paying - by debit card or cash since they don’t take credit cards. She was handling it better then I was.

They say women are more mentally tough than men, something to do with childbirth. I don’t know if that is true, but she didn’t even bat an eye when the cashier told her that they don’t supply shopping bags. If you wanted them, you have to pay for them a la carte. I almost stabbed the cashier with one of the imitation slim jims by the register, as I was convinced she was some inter-dimensional monster (think Cthulhu), but my wife simply said thank you and calmly walked out of the store with the box under her arm.

It took a few minutes for me to calm down. It is jarring to fall into a wormhole. They say most people throw up the first time they travel between dimensions, I am happy to say that I managed to keep my lunch down. In reality I was bemused by the store. I had this smug superiority and I felt like I was better then shopping at Aldi’s. Yes, part of me wanted to shop here, because it was really, really cheap. But I also felt that people like me don’t shop at discount food stores. I knew that I wanted to write a blog entry on this. When we got home, while my wife cooked dinner, I went on Google and did some research.

I was shocked at what I found. Aldi’s is a subsidiary of ALDI Einkauf GmbH, a German company that was founded by Karl and Theo Albrecht - the two richest men in German.  They have since retired (one died), but Aldi’s, which is divided into two operating regions Nord (North) and Sud (South), is one of the largest supermarket chains in the world. I was sure their products came from the most exploitive factory in China, but they are actually mostly European. Their business model is to keep costs low cost by eliminating extras, like bags and paying fees to credit card companies. They even make you put a quarter into a receptacle on the shopping cart to release it. Your money is then refunded if you return the cart to the kiosk outside the store. This eliminates the need to pay someone to collect the carts from the parking lot. The only place they don’t take short cuts is with the quality of the food.

How do I know this, you ask. Well, I went into the store feeling like that condescendingly smug girl who sings "The People of Wal-Mart" song. I can’t stand her, but I finally understood her. It was comical watching all the plebeians scurry about for their discount crusts of bread. I was more accustomed to eating organic, free-range cake. This self-aggrandizement lasted until I learned that ALDI Einkauf GmbH is also the parent company Trader Joes.

Yes, that Trader Joes - Mecca of suburban bourge-ness and edgy alternative to Whole Foods. The store staffed with college hipsters and stocked with tapenade and wild caught / flash frozen king salmon. According to the Internet, the food is sourced from the same vendors and shipped from the same warehouses. Aldi’s uses a different private label name and packaging then the products destined for Trader Joes. The only material difference is that the priced are jacked up because the latter is "gourmet."

Two things occurred to me. First, I am shockingly easy to manipulate. I like to think of myself as this worldly, urbane, New Yorker. I am smarter then the average sheep and far to sophisticated to fall prey to some marketing campaign. I am proud of my on my counter culture rejection of popular opinion and dedication to intellectual non-conformity.   

I have to be honest, it broke me down when I found out that is all crap. Some very smart people, smarter then me apparently, design a food store that caters to my specific self-image, and I didn’t even know it. My own self-importance and Trader Joes’s fancy labels and cute hippy cashiers blinded me.  I also realized that if I shop at Aldi’s I could save about 40 percent of my weekly food budget.

Between being manipulated and the chance to save money, I feel like I should apologize to Aldi’s. I don’t know how to perform an act of contrition to a supermarket, but it is a good start is to say that I am going to try to do my weekly food shopping there this weekend.

I call on you to abandon your illusions of supermarket privilege and join me on the barricades of brand liberation. Be the Marius to my Val Jean, and let the people sing the songs of hungry men - just sing them at 40 percent off at Aldi’s. Viva La Revolution!

I hope you enjoyed this week’s entry. Please check out my other blog at http://littlejimmysfood.blogspot.com. I am currently publishing a series on my favorite places on the East End of Long Island. Part two of my East End trip should be up shortly. Please let me know what you think about Aldi’s and anything else that is on your mind. I look forward to hearing from you and responding to you comments.

Aldi Supermarket, 139 Alexander Avenue, Lake Grove, NY 11755

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Edward Norton May 11, 2012 at 05:28 PM
Its funny. I just went into one of these while upstate looking at colleges for my daughter. We were amazed by all the rip-offs of actual products there. Their version of sugar smacks cereal had a giant fish character on it instead of good ole dig em, the frog. We both thought yuck, a fish on a cereal box. Then we thought, hmm, is a frog any better? LOL. I guess its what youre used to that seems normal. I cant comment on the quality of the stuff but the place definitely had that Stepford wife vibe to it.
K. May 11, 2012 at 06:17 PM
This all reminds me of when I was a kid and Mom would buy "store-brand" instead of the "real" brand; she always said: "It's all made in the same factory!"
James Dowd May 11, 2012 at 07:11 PM
K. - in this case it is literally made in the same factory. Mom's are so smart! Happy Mother's day all you smart mommies!
K.A.C. May 13, 2012 at 05:00 PM
Haven't gotten one thing at Aldi's that wasn't great!! Best frozen Cheddar Bacon burgers we've ever had! I urge everyone to give it a try. The store doesn't disappoint!
Michael Walters May 13, 2012 at 05:08 PM
They are owned by the same company at Trader Joes
Matthew Lott May 13, 2012 at 05:22 PM
Somewhat of a monopoly going on there to unsuspecting shoppers.
MS May 15, 2012 at 02:11 PM
What a wonderfully writen article! I thoroughly enjoy your writing style James! I will be checking out Aldi as well!!
s May 16, 2012 at 05:47 AM
Agree with MS!! Great article!! Literally LOL quite a few times... probably because I went into Aldi the first time this past weekend and immediately paused in the doorway (yes, entering a wormhole is daunting!) to take it all in and decide on how to navigate. Paid 6 cents for a bag (didnt plan on shopping but next time will be bringing the recycled bags) and bought a FULL bag of stuff for 10 bucks. CHEAP CHEAP!! Loved the article, had a hunch about the parent company being something big, but was thinking COOP (Europe) or Ikea. Thanks for sharing the info James!!! I know I will be going back this weekend!
D May 16, 2012 at 01:29 PM
Your article made me laugh hysterical! When they first opened I went in there and it was strange that is was rather empty and I first thought, like you, that there were Brand names, but upon closer investigation the were not. Do you remember "Stepford Wives"? that's how I felt- just gliding along with my cart and looking at all the new and different items like they came from another universe!!! I'm just cracking up about your article - I love it! After leaving Aldi's I felt, I don't think I'll go back-felt like I was shopping in a WIC/foodstamp center, but I've been back twice and plan on going back. Something keeps drawing me back there! IS it the cheaper prices, the good food, I really don't know, but it's great for discounted items and my kids even like the foods that aren't name brands! Thanks for your great sense of humor!
James Dowd May 16, 2012 at 02:01 PM
Thank you! You are literally making me blush.
James Dowd May 16, 2012 at 02:01 PM
Lol - my wife said the article was strange. I was actually feeling very insecure! Thanks for the positive feedback
James Dowd May 16, 2012 at 02:03 PM
I actually have no sense of humor. Instead I have a complete lack of self awareness that leads to an awkward irony that seems, strangely, witty.
James Dowd May 16, 2012 at 02:03 PM
Hey Matt - more of a monopoly when you consider that Trader Joes and Aldi's are within a mile of each other - both on the outskirts of the mall!
D May 16, 2012 at 02:34 PM
You and my hisband would get along great!
Matthew Lott May 16, 2012 at 03:00 PM
James thanks for exposing them to us !
CAS May 17, 2012 at 02:15 AM
Regular Aldis' shopper in previous Midwestern town, though I was slow to appreciate. Have nothing against saving $$, but didn't want to compromise food quality. Shopped one day with a savy friend, tried a couple things. Years later, I can say my family's never been disappointed in anything from Aldis. Take a cart-quarter, go! Save some $$!
interested May 17, 2012 at 03:50 AM
Enjoyed your article. Your amends to Aldi's may be in the new customers you've encouraged to try them. I'm put off by Trader Joe's trendiness, so Aldi's might be the place for me. I like to re-use my bags and LOVE to save on food! Thanks for the insight and the chuckle!
Matthew Lott May 17, 2012 at 03:59 AM
Look, that may have been "nice" in a Midwestern Town where these shops are not a "dime a dozen", but we are More sophisticated here, and have more choices than you had there. Especially when you are looking for alleged "choices", 24/7 as part of your Shopping Regimen. A "trick" like being the Same Owner, of the same type of "upscale" convenience store, located just a short distance away from each other, is enough reason feel like one is being Ripped Off in one of them. It's not only off-putting, but it's nonetheless devious when it's revealed. They don't "get it" yet, but once The Word spreads, it will have some economic repercussions for the them Both, and it's back to their wily, German "draft boards" and damage control time, to figure a way "out" of the self-made Problem, that they designed, so craftily for themselves.
Horst November 29, 2012 at 11:40 AM
It is funny, it seems like the shopping behaviour of germans is different. If I, as a german myself, want to buy something, I do not look for brands. At first I check the price per kilogram (metric system), and then I read through the description, to find out what is healthier and to find out the reason why one product is more expensive than another product. Due to smaller supermarkets there will be for example just two different kinds of Wiener sausages -> easy decision. Maybe the amount of advertisement which you face every day is also different in Germany. It is common in Germany to have a sticker at your mailbox which says "No advertisement please". I also know many people who do not have a television. It is considered as waste of time. So the number of brands which you recognize in your daily life is low.
Damien February 18, 2013 at 01:36 PM
I enjoyed this piece simply because it does essentially what my blog often does. I live to expose truth and/or stupidity in all human endeavor, yet your voice -- with that little dash of Irma Bombeck -- defies assault or rancor. I would have played up that Aldi and Trader Joe's angle mercilessly, and for that I would have been boiled in oil. Perhaps my every blog entry is a form of importuning, but lucky for Aldi that Damien LeGallienne -- that's me -- didn't get a hold of this first. Notwithstanding the fact that I do not like homespun stuff, I am going to give you a nod next week in TheDamienZone, and getting a "backlink" like that will boost your visibility enormously. Now don't go and pump out just anything. You have set your own bar -- keep it where it is, thank you. Damien

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »