Updated: Locals Debate New York City Marathon Decision

Did New York City make the right decision to cancel the Marathon this Sunday?

Update: The New York City Marathon has been cancelled, according to news reports.

The race must go on. That’s the word from Mayor Michael Bloomberg who says they have the resources to ensure both the safety of residents affected by Hurricane Sandy and to manage the thousands of runners and spectators for this year’s New York City Marathon.

The 26.2-mile race through all five boroughs of New York City starts in Staten Island, the hardest hit. Many saying that the decision to go on is a bad one.

The debate on the New York Road Runners Facebook page is heating up with commenters chastising the organization that runs the marathon for being insensitive to those affected by Hurricane Sandy.

Locally, opinions vary.

Wendy Frazier, a Port Jefferson Station resident, ran in the New York City Marathon last year.

“I am not running this year, but even if I was, I would defer,” she told Patch. “I don't think the marathon should be held right now.”

Even though the marathon runners train for months and it takes a tremendous amount of planning while contributing to the city’s economy, Frazier said it will take away from people who are in need.

“The resources that are being put towards the marathon (extra police, generators, hotel rooms, cooling stations and the closing of major bridges) only diverts those much needed resources from the people who need it most,” she said.

On the other hand, Port Jefferson resident Don Nenninger thinks that people need an event like the marathon to lift their spirits.

“We can often get caught up in the hype of popular events, forgetting that the essence of competition is the triumph of the spirit over the challenges that life will always present,” he said. “The marathon in its simplest terms is a run and running is a great way to move towards meeting the latest challenge in your life.”

People travel from around the world to participate in the marathon and Nenninger said that if New York City can handle the logistics it should be held.

The New York Road Runners Club was quick to rebranded the marathon as a “Race to Recover.” It will donate at least $1 million to charities involved in relief efforts, including the Mayor’s Fund and the American Red Cross, according its the website.

“I know that I will be encouraged to watch the run even though it's been a tough week,” Nenninger said. “It's a positive and inspiring activity.”

But like many outraged people posting to Facebook, politicians and others who have criticized Mayor Bloomberg for continuing to hold the race, Frazier says it’s not the right thing to do right now.

“It is (in my opinion) incredibly insensitive to the people of Staten Island, the city, New Jersey and Long Island who are trying to ‘just survive,’” she said.

The New York Roadrunners Club suggest ways to donate to help the relief effort in New York. To donate through the Mayor’s Fund, please click here. Visit NYRR's fundraising platform CrowdRise, to donate to a variety of Hurricane Sandy relief efforts. From your mobile phone, text "redcross" to 90999 to donate $10 through your wireless carrier.

June Kelly November 04, 2012 at 12:26 PM
Very good decision. I do fell bad for those that came so far, many of which were probably here before Sandy hit so an earlier call would not have made a difference. Now many of the runners are contributing to the relief fund and that's a good thing. So many people need help I pray for them all.
BirthdayGifts March 23, 2013 at 08:42 AM
Birthday Gifts are not always about cake and flowers. Reinventing your gifts is a must if you are looking for variety. You can try one of these Wedding Gifts ideas to make a your special mark on the occassion: Flowers were used to express what words sometimes could not. That tradition continues today. Whether we wish to express congratulations, offer sympathy, good wishes, or express our love to others, Anniversary Gifts speak for us when we can't find the words we wish to say. No other gift conveys the meaning from the heart like sending Soap Flowers Suitable for cleaning hand, face, bath and etc. simply toss a handful of bath confetti under running water and allow the Gift Ideas Easy to carry. Applicable in home, trip, hotel, office and etc. http://www.buyuniquegifts.net/


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »